UCAT SJT Appropriateness Questions

Rate responses using professional standards and GMC Good Medical Practice.

Written and reviewed by Dr Akash Gandhi, NHS GP (GMC 7601216) and founder of TheUKCATPeople, teaching the UCAT since 2012. Last reviewed .

Frequently asked questions

How do UCAT SJT appropriateness questions work?

You read a short scenario, often involving a medical or dental student or a doctor, followed by several possible responses. You rate each response on a four point scale: very appropriate, appropriate but not ideal, inappropriate but not awful, or very inappropriate. Each rating counts as one of the 69 SJT questions. The middle two ratings matter most: appropriate but not ideal means it helps but has a drawback, while inappropriate but not awful means it is unhelpful without causing real harm.

How are SJT appropriateness questions marked?

In the real UCAT, the keyed rating earns full marks and a nearby rating earns partial marks, and your SJT total becomes a Band from 1 to 4. The costly error is landing on the wrong side of the line between appropriate and inappropriate. Rating a very appropriate response as inappropriate is two steps out and scores nothing in this trainer, while rating it appropriate still earns half a mark. Decide which side of that line a response sits first, then decide how far.

What are the most common mistakes in SJT appropriateness questions?

Adding facts the scenario does not give you is the commonest, closely followed by judging what you would realistically do rather than what a conscientious student or doctor should do. Candidates also rate any response that involves telling a senior as very appropriate, whatever the timing or urgency. Watch for responses that go beyond the person's competence, such as a student giving clinical advice, and for responses that fix the immediate problem by breaching confidentiality or bending the truth.

Can you show a worked example of an SJT appropriateness question?

Suppose a medical student on placement takes a phone call from someone asking about a patient's diagnosis. Explaining politely that they cannot share information and suggesting the caller speaks to the patient is very appropriate: it protects confidentiality and is courteous. Sharing the diagnosis because the caller sounds worried is very inappropriate, because it breaches confidentiality. The middle ratings are for responses that are safe but could be better, or unhelpful but cause no real harm.

How quickly should I answer SJT appropriateness questions?

With 69 questions in 26 minutes you have about 22 seconds per rated response, but the scenario takes longest to read. Read it once carefully, noting who you are, what has gone wrong and whether anyone is at risk right now. Each response should then take only a few seconds. If you are stuck between two ratings, choose the one you can best justify, flag the question and move on, rather than spending a minute on one item.

How does the Appropriateness Rater work?

Choose a GMC domain and a difficulty level (Foundation, Standard or Challenging), or leave both open, then start a scenario. You rate one response at a time and confirm it to see the keyed rating, a full rationale and, when you miss, why the neighbouring rating does not fit. The trainer holds 150 appropriateness scenarios. Any scenario where you drop a mark joins your mistake reviews and comes back 24 hours later for a retry from memory.